Anthrax - Health Hazard or Hoax?
Donald E. Low,
MD
Department of Microbiology,
Toronto Medical Laboratories and Mount Sinai Hospital
During the recent past there has been concern about
the possibility of terrorist attacks using biological weapons. This
concern has been heightened by the occurrence of a case of "inhalation
anthrax" in Florida, in association with the identification
of the same anthrax spores in the nose of two fellow employees and
its detection on the victim's computer keyboard. Prior to the Florida
incident, there have been hundreds of mailed or telephoned bioterrorism
threats, usually claiming that anthrax had been released. All were
hoaxes resulting in thousands of potential victims being treated
with antibiotics and decontamination procedures. These hoaxes prove
to be extremely costly both in terms of concern and dollars.
There are numerous biological agents that could potentially
be used as terrorist weapons including Bacillus anthracis
(anthrax), smallpox, Francisella tularensis (tularemia),
Yersinia pestis (plague) and botulinum toxin from Clostridium
botulinum. Of these, anthrax is felt to be the most likely
organism to be used for such purposes. The likelihood that these
agents could be used as a bioterrorist weapon is possible but unlikely.
In fact, even though anthrax has been at the top of the list of
"the most likely agent to be used in a bioterrorist attack",
to the best of our knowledge, other than the one possible case as
a result of an intentional release of anthrax in Florida , this
agent has never been successfully used in bioterrorist attacks.
Anthrax is a serious bacterial infection that occurs
when Bacillus anthracis spores enter the body through abrasions
in the skin or by inhalation or ingestion. Most mammals, especially
plant eating animals that graze for food (eg. cattle, goats, sheep,
camels), can develop infecton. Human infections result from contact
with contaminated animals or animal products, and there are no known
cases of human-to-human transmission. Human anthrax is not common.
Only 18 cases of inhalation anthrax have been reported in North
America in the last century, the last case being in 1976. Cases
of cutaneous anthrax have occurred previously in North America,
usually related to spores on goat or sheep hair imported from counties
where anthrax is endemic. Cutaneous anthrax, the most common form,
is usually curable when treated with antibiotics. Systemic infection
resulting from inhalation of the organism (inhalation or pulmonary
anthrax) has a very high mortality rate, with death usually occurring
within a few days after the onset of symptoms. When initiated early
during the incubation period, antibiotics are very effective in
treating anthrax. The rapid course of the disease once symptoms
appear make early treatment an absolute necessity.
Humans can acquire anthrax by agricultural or industrial
exposure to infected animals or animal products either by direct
contact or by breathing in spores released from hides or hair. More
recently, the potential for intentional release of anthrax spores
in the environment has caused much concern. However, creating a
form of anthrax that would be able to be aerosolized is difficult
since the spores have a natural tendency to clump together and not
remain in the air. In addition, the environmental conditions (i.e.,
air movement and humidity) must be exact in order to ensure adequate
aerosolization. The fact that an apparent bioterrorist attack in
Florida only resulted in illness in one person is evidence for the
difficulty in weaponizing this agent. One terrorist group in Japan,
dispersed aerosols of anthrax and botulism in Tokyo on at least
8 occasions without producing any illness in the citizens of Tokyo.
Whether introduced in a letter or released in the environment
directly, the success of distributing a large enough amount of anthrax
spores to infect large numbers of individuals in a single building
or closed environment would be very unlikely. Air sampled in goat-hair-processing
plants was found to be contaminated with spores, yet workers did
not come down with disease. It is thought that in order to infect
50% of persons that an exposure of between 8,000 and 10,000 spores
would be required.
Typically, if anthrax was used in a bioterrorist attack,
terrorists would be attempting to cause inhalation anthrax-that
is the type that causes disease after exposure to aerosolized anthrax.
Inhalation anthrax usually presents in two phases. The incubation
period is from 1 to 6 days. The initial stage, continuing for an
average of 4 days, begins with the insidious onset of muscle aches,
malaise, fatigue, nonproductive cough, and fever. There may be a
transient improvement after the first few days. The second stage,
lasting 24 h and often culminating in death, develops suddenly with
the onset of acute respiratory distress. Meningitis occurs in up
to 50% of cases.
There has been much concern about how individuals can
protect themselves if anthrax is introduced into an environment
or someone becomes infected. Stockpiling gas masks and antibiotics
is not the answer. Do not touch suspicious packages, report them
immediately to the appropriate authorities, and co-operate with
individuals whose responsibility it is to implement emergency procedures
if exposure has occurred.
Transmission of anthrax from an infected person to another
individual has never been described. Infected people do not excrete
enough spores to cause a danger to people who care for them. Their
blood and body fluids are not infectious. Therefore there is no
concern about coming in contact with persons infected with anthrax
once post-exposure decontamination procedures have been performed.
In health care settings no additional precautions are necessary
in providing care to these individuals and there is no risk to friends
or families of patients with the disease.
Hospitals, laboratories, public health departments and
emergency service personnel have a role to play in early identification
and detection of possible bioterrorism threats. Emergency room staff
and first responders need to be alert for the appearance of unusual
presentations of common disease (i.e., pneumonia) or clusters of
cases of common diseases. Laboratories should be prepared to process
clinical specimens and identify potential pathogens, such as B.
anthracis. Public Health organizations are ready to manage
exposed individuals and environments in the event of a suspected
bioterrorism attack.
Link to related
material on site
|